Hawthorne and His Market: A Cultural Studies Perspective

 

Hawthorne and His Market: A Cultural Studies Perspective

   

Personal Information

Name: Jayshri R. Khachar 

Enrollment No: 5108230023

Sem: 3 (M.A)

Batch: 2023-2025

Paper Name:205A: Cultural Studies

Submitted To: Smt, S.B.gardi , Department of English, m.k.b.u

Dated on: 20/10/2024

Email id: jayshrikhachar4@gmail.com

Table of Contents

Introduction

Hawthorne’s Literary Significance

Cultural Studies Framework

Hawthorne’s Cultural and Economic Context

The Antebellum Literary Marketplace

The Rise of the Professional Author

Hawthorne’s Position in the Market

Audience and Reception

Patronage, Publishing, and Financial Struggles

Themes Reflecting Cultural and Market Dynamics

Individualism and Community

Critique of Puritanical Morality

Gender and Domesticity

Hawthorne and Ideological Critique

The American Dream and Class Consciousness

The Market’s Influence on Literary Style

Legacy and Relevance

Hawthorne in Contemporary Cultural Studies

Ongoing Debates About Authorial Autonomy

Conclusion

References

Hawthorne and His Market: A Cultural Studies Perspective

Abstract

Nathaniel Hawthorne, an eminent 19th-century American author, remains a pivotal figure in American literature, often celebrated for his exploration of morality, guilt, and the human condition. However, the understanding of Hawthorne’s work also demands an analysis of the socio-economic and cultural market within which his writing was produced and consumed. This paper examines Hawthorne’s relationship with his market through the lens of Cultural Studies, focusing on how the economic and ideological contexts of his time shaped his writing and how his works reflect and critique the dominant cultural narratives of antebellum America. By employing Cultural Studies methodologies, the paper underscores the reciprocal relationship between Hawthorne and the socio-cultural environment of his readership.

Key Words

thorne's Significance, Cultural Studies, 19th Century Literature, Economic Context, Literary Marketplace, Professional Author, Publishing, Market Dynamics, Audience Reception, Patronage, Social Class, Individualism, Puritan Morality, Gender Roles, Ideological Criticism, American Dream, Literary Style, Legacy, Authorial Autonomy, Commercial Success.

Introduction

Nathaniel Hawthorne’s legacy in American literature is undeniable, with works like The Scarlet Letter and The House of the Seven Gables considered classics. However, an analysis of Hawthorne cannot be confined to his literary artistry alone. As Cultural Studies emphasizes, literature exists within a web of economic, cultural, and ideological forces. Understanding Hawthorne's relationship with his market—the publishing industry, readership expectations, and prevailing cultural ideologies—enriches our interpretation of his works.

Cultural Studies, an interdisciplinary approach that interrogates the intersection of culture, power, and society, provides a useful framework for this exploration. By analyzing Hawthorne through this lens, we can see how his works were both shaped by and shaped the socio-cultural and economic conditions of his time.

Hawthorne’s Cultural and Economic Context

The Antebellum Literary Marketplace

The 19th century marked significant changes in the American literary marketplace. The expansion of print culture, coupled with increased literacy rates, transformed the production and consumption of literature. Magazines, journals, and newspapers proliferated, providing new opportunities for writers. However, this burgeoning market also created competitive pressures, as writers had to cater to public tastes while navigating the constraints imposed by publishers.

Hawthorne entered this dynamic literary scene at a time when American literature was still striving for cultural independence from European traditions. Writers like Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow sought to establish a distinctly American voice, and Hawthorne’s works contributed to this cultural project. However, his market was not merely a space of artistic expression; it was also an economic system where financial viability often dictated creative choices.

The Rise of the Professional Author

The professionalization of authorship during Hawthorne’s time was fraught with challenges. Unlike earlier periods, when writers often relied on patronage, the 19th century saw a shift toward commercial publishing. Authors increasingly depended on book sales, magazine contributions, and advances to sustain their livelihoods. Hawthorne’s career reflects this transition, as he struggled to balance his literary aspirations with the demands of the market.

Hawthorne’s Position in the Market

Audience and Reception

Hawthorne’s works were primarily aimed at a middle-class audience, which had both the means and the leisure to engage with literature. This audience valued moral instruction, entertainment, and reflections on social values—all of which Hawthorne incorporated into his writings. However, he often critiqued the very cultural norms his audience upheld, creating a tension between his creative goals and market expectations.

Patronage, Publishing, and Financial Struggles

Hawthorne’s early career was marked by financial insecurity. His first major work, Twice-Told Tales, was published with little financial reward, despite critical acclaim. Hawthorne’s struggles to find a stable source of income led him to take a government job at the Salem Custom House, an experience he later satirized in the introduction to The Scarlet Letter. Even as his reputation grew, Hawthorne remained acutely aware of the economic pressures facing authors, often lamenting the commercial compromises required to succeed in the literary market.

Themes Reflecting Cultural and Market Dynamics

Individualism and Community

One of the central themes in Hawthorne’s work is the tension between individualism and community. This theme reflects the broader cultural concerns of antebellum America, where the market economy and democratic ideals often clashed with traditional communal values. In The Scarlet Letter, for instance, Hester Prynne’s defiance of Puritan norms embodies a critique of societal constraints, while her ultimate reintegration into the community suggests a nuanced negotiation between individual freedom and collective belonging.

Critique of Puritanical Morality

Hawthorne’s works frequently critique the moral absolutism of Puritan society. This critique resonates with his market, as 19th-century readers grappled with the legacies of Puritanism in a rapidly modernizing society. By addressing these cultural anxieties, Hawthorne’s works appealed to contemporary readers while also offering a deeper critique of historical and cultural norms.

Gender and Domesticity

The antebellum period saw the rise of the "cult of domesticity," which idealized women’s roles as moral guardians within the home. Hawthorne’s portrayal of women, from Hester Prynne to Hepzibah Pyncheon (The House of the Seven Gables), engages with these cultural narratives. While his female characters often embody traditional virtues, they also challenge and subvert the constraints of their roles, reflecting the complexities of gender dynamics in his time.

Hawthorne and Ideological Critique

The American Dream and Class Consciousness

Hawthorne’s works often explore the darker sides of the American Dream, particularly its implications for class and social mobility. In The House of the Seven Gables, the Pyncheon family’s decline serves as a critique of greed, corruption, and the false promises of wealth. This theme resonated with readers in an era of growing economic inequality, highlighting the ideological contradictions within the market economy.

The Market’s Influence on Literary Style

The demands of the market also influenced Hawthorne’s literary style. His reliance on allegory and symbolism allowed him to address complex moral and philosophical questions while remaining accessible to his audience. However, this stylistic choice was not merely a market strategy; it also reflected Hawthorne’s ambivalence toward the commodification of literature. By embedding multiple layers of meaning in his works, Hawthorne resisted the market’s tendency to reduce literature to mere entertainment.

Legacy and Relevance

Legacy and Relevance: Hawthorne in Contemporary Cultural Studies

Nathaniel Hawthorne's body of work remains highly relevant in contemporary cultural studies, especially in how it interacts with the cultural and economic forces of its time. As a writer, Hawthorne was acutely aware of the complex relationship between art and commerce. His works, such as The Scarlet Letter, The House of the Seven Gables, and The Blithedale Romance, not only engage with the moral and social dilemmas of his day but also reflect the evolving economic conditions in 19th-century America.

Hawthorne's literature offers a sharp critique of the American market economy, particularly its influence on personal identity, social relations, and morality. In The Scarlet Letter, for instance, the puritanical community's response to Hester Prynne's sin can be seen as an allegory for the way the market-driven society commodifies individuals, reducing their worth to their roles as consumers or sinners. This theme of the tension between individual autonomy and societal expectations resonates with modern discussions about identity, economic systems, and the commodification of personal narratives.

Hawthorne’s engagement with his market further illustrates his awareness of the economic conditions under which he wrote. While he certainly sought to uphold artistic standards, he was also very much aware of the commercial demands of publishing and public reception. His ability to balance these often conflicting forces—producing works that both critiqued and catered to the market—makes him a fascinating subject for cultural studies. His literary career underscores the broader questions of how literature functions in a market-driven society, raising critical inquiries about the role of writers as both creators of art and participants in the economic systems of their time.

Ongoing Debates About Authorial Autonomy

Hawthorne’s career provides a nuanced lens through which to examine the concept of authorial autonomy in a market-driven literary world. His personal correspondence and diaries reveal his constant struggle between maintaining his artistic integrity and meeting the demands of a commercial publishing world. While he was committed to producing high-quality, thought-provoking works, he also understood the pressures of earning a living as a writer in a market economy. This tension is especially evident in his relationship with publishers, his feelings of frustration regarding the reception of his work, and his awareness of the public’s taste, which often shaped his writing choices.

This tension between artistic freedom and market necessity is a central theme in contemporary cultural studies, where scholars grapple with the complexities of authorship in an era where creative freedom is often constrained by market forces. For Hawthorne, the question of how much control he had over his own work—especially when compared to the expectations and needs of his publishers and audience—is a key issue. He both shaped and was shaped by the commercial landscape of his time, navigating the fine line between artistic expression and market expectations.

In many ways, this tension remains relevant today as authors continue to balance the desire for creative autonomy with the need to make a living and cater to their audience’s tastes. The increasing commodification of literature, in the form of digital publishing, best-seller lists, and marketing strategies, has only deepened the question of whether a writer can ever truly maintain autonomy in a capitalist framework. Hawthorne's work serves as an early and enduring example of this ongoing debate, highlighting the complex relationship between the artistic and commercial forces that shape authorship.

In conclusion, Hawthorne’s legacy offers valuable insights into the intersection of art, commerce, and authorial autonomy, making him a crucial figure in cultural studies. His works continue to provoke critical discussions on how literature reflects, critiques, and is influenced by the economic and cultural conditions of its time, offering timeless lessons on the challenges of balancing artistic integrity with market demands.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Hawthorne’s legacy offers valuable insights into the intersection of art, commerce, and authorial autonomy, making him a crucial figure in cultural studies. His works continue to provoke critical discussions on how literature reflects, critiques, and is influenced by the economic and cultural conditions of its time, offering timeless lessons on the challenges of balancing artistic integrity with market demands.Nathaniel Hawthorne’s relationship with his market offers a compelling case study in Cultural Studies. By examining his economic and cultural context, we gain a deeper understanding of how his works were shaped by and responded to the conditions of antebellum America. Hawthorne’s ability to critique the very cultural norms that sustained his market reflects the complexities of his position as a professional author. Ultimately, his legacy underscores the intricate interplay between literature, culture, and commerce—a dynamic that remains relevant in contemporary discussions of authorship and market forces.

References

Britannica, The Editors of Encyclopaedia. "Nathaniel Hawthorne". Encyclopedia Britannica, 25 Oct. 2024, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Nathaniel-Hawthorne. Accessed 2 November 2024.

Casper, Scott E. “The Two Lives of Franklin Pierce: Hawthorne, Political Culture, and the Literary Market.” American Literary History, vol. 5, no. 2, 1993, pp. 203–30. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/489745. Accessed 2 Nov. 2024.

David Greven. “Introduction: Hawthorne and Influence: Reframing Tradition.” Nathaniel Hawthorne Review, vol. 42, no. 1, 2016, pp. 1–15. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5325/nathhawtrevi.42.1.0001. Accessed 2 Nov. 2024.

EGAN, KEN. “THE ADULTERESS IN THE MARKET-PLACE: HAWTHORNE AND ‘THE SCARLET LETTER.’” Studies in the Novel, vol. 27, no. 1, 1995, pp. 26–41. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/29533028. Accessed 2 Nov. 2024.

Folsom, James K. Man's Accidents and God’s Purposes: Nathaniel Hawthorne's Puritan Conversion. Archon Books, 1968.

Gilmore, Michael T. American Romanticism and the Marketplace. University of Chicago Press, 1985.

Hawthorne, Nathaniel. The Scarlet Letter. Penguin Classics, 2002.

Lemire, Elise Virginia. Miscegenation: Making Race in America. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2002.

words count:2085