Saturday, 25 November 2023

Assignment 103: A Comparative Analysis of "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen and "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi

 Assignment 103: Literature of the Romantics


This blog is Part of an Assignment For the Paper 105A - History of English literature -From 1350 to 1900, Sem - 1,2023.


A Comparative Analysis of "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen and "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi




Table of content 


  • Personal information 
  • Assignment Details 
  • Introduction
  • Setting and social context
  • Character parallels
  • Themes
  • Love and transformation
  • Cultural adaptation
  • Conclusion
  • Reference 


Personal information 


Name: Jayshri Khachar

Batch: M.A Sem: 1 (2023 - 2025)

Enrollment No: 5108230023

Email id: jayshrikhachar4@gmail.com

Roll number: 16


Assignment Details 


Topic : A Comparative Analysis of "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen and "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi

Paper :  103 Literature of the Romantics

Submitted to: Smt. S B Gardi, Department of English, MKBU, Bhavnagar

Submition date: 1 December, 2023




Introduction:



Literature has the remarkable ability to transcend time and cultural boundaries, connecting readers across centuries and continents through shared themes and universal human experiences. In this comparative analysis, we delve into the worlds created by two accomplished authors, Jane Austen and Ibi Zoboi, examining the timeless themes of social class, love, and personal growth in their respective works—"Pride and Prejudice" and "Pride." Despite being separated by centuries and cultural contexts, both novels explore the intricacies of pride, prejudice, and the transformative power of love in a way that resonates with readers across diverse backgrounds.


Austen's "Pride and Prejudice," a classic of English literature serves as a lens into a society bound by rigid social hierarchies and expectations. Through the eyes of characters like Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy, Austen intricately weaves a narrative that challenges societal norms, explores the consequences of pride and prejudice, and ultimately celebrates the redemptive nature of love.


In contrast, Ibi Zoboi's "Pride" transports readers infusing the narrative with contemporary issues such as gentrification, racial dynamics, and cultural identity. Zoboi skillfully reimagines Austen's timeless themes within a diverse and urban context, where characters navigate the complexities of love and social expectations in a rapidly changing world.


As we embark on this comparative journey, our aim is to uncover the parallels and divergences in the treatment of these themes by Austen and Zoboi. By examining the evolution of societal norms, the role of personal growth in character development, and the transformative power of love in both novels.



Setting and Social Context


  • Pride and Prejudice:



"Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen is primarily set in the early 19th century in rural England. The story unfolds against the backdrop of the Regency era, a period marked by the rule of King George III in the early 1800s. The novel is primarily situated in the fictional towns and estates of Hertfordshire, Derbyshire, and Kent.


While the novel primarily unfolds in these rural and estate settings, the characters' movements and interactions are also influenced by the broader social context of the time, where social class and reputation played crucial roles in determining one's place in society and the possibilities for marriage. Austen's portrayal of this society provides a rich backdrop for exploring themes of love, pride, and social expectations in "Pride and Prejudice."



  • Pride:







"Pride" by Ibi Zoboi is set in contemporary Brooklyn, New York. The novel transports Jane Austen's classic "Pride and Prejudice" into a modern urban setting, infusing the narrative with the vibrancy and diversity of a Brooklyn neighborhood undergoing significant changes.


By setting "Pride" in a contemporary urban environment, Ibi Zoboi engages with issues such as gentrification, cultural identity, and the clash between tradition and modernity. The novel reflects the complexities of navigating love and social expectations in a diverse and evolving community, offering a fresh perspective on the timeless themes explored in Jane Austen's "Pride and Prejudice."


Character Parallels:



In "Pride and Prejudice," the dynamic characters of Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy have left an indelible mark on literature. Their distinct personalities and the evolution of their relationship serve as a timeless exploration of love, class, and personal growth. In the modern counterpart, "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi introduces Zuri Benitez and Darius Darcy, characters who echo the spirit of Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy in a contemporary urban setting.


Elizabeth Bennet and Zuri Benitez:


  •   Strength and Independence:








 Elizabeth Bennet is known for her intelligence, wit, and independent spirit. Zuri Benitez, the counterpart in "Pride," shares these qualities. Zuri is a strong-willed, confident young woman navigating the challenges of a changing neighborhood in Brooklyn.


Mr. Darcy and Darius Darcy:


  •   Pride and Social Status:







 Mr. Darcy's initial pride and social aloofness shape the narrative of "Pride and Prejudice." Darius Darcy, the modern iteration, grapples with similar challenges. As a successful entrepreneur in a gentrifying neighborhood, Darius faces issues of perception and social status, mirroring Mr. Darcy's struggle with pride and societal expectations.


By drawing these parallels, "Pride" not only pays homage to the classic characters but also explores how their timeless traits and challenges manifest in a contemporary, culturally diverse setting. The character dynamics provide a bridge between two worlds, emphasizing the enduring relevance of Austen's themes in the modern narrative crafted by Ibi Zoboi.


Themes 


"Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen explores several themes that remain central to the novel's enduring appeal. Two overarching themes are evident throughout the narrative:


1. Pride:

   

 The novel delves into the consequences of excessive pride, particularly within the context of social class. Characters such as Mr. Darcy initially exhibit a sense of superiority due to their social standing, leading to misunderstandings and conflicts.


Beyond social distinctions, individual characters, including Elizabeth Bennet, grapple with personal pride. Elizabeth's initial prejudices against Mr. Darcy and her own misconceptions highlight the impact of pride on personal relationships and growth.


2. Prejudice:


 The novel underscores the detrimental effects of societal prejudices based on class, wealth, and reputation. Characters form judgments about each other without a full understanding, contributing to societal divisions and misunderstandings.

   

 The characters, notably Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy, confront their own personal prejudices. Through self-reflection and personal growth, they learn to overcome these biases, emphasizing the transformative power of overcoming individual prejudices.


3. Love and Marriage:


    The theme of love and marriage is central to the novel. The characters navigate societal expectations and individual desires in the pursuit of genuine and meaningful connections. The contrasting relationships, such as Jane Bennet and Mr. Bingley's amiable courtship and Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy's more complex journey, provide insights into different facets of love and matrimony.


4. Social Expectations:


   The novel critiques the rigid social expectations of the time, particularly the pressure to marry well and adhere to societal norms. Characters like Elizabeth challenge these expectations, seeking authentic connections based on mutual respect and understanding.


5. Individual Growth:


   The narrative emphasizes the importance of personal growth and self-awareness. Characters evolve over the course of the novel, challenging their own preconceptions and biases. Elizabeth's journey, in particular, exemplifies the transformative nature of self-reflection and personal development.


6. Irony and Satire:


 Austen employs irony and satire to critique the social norms and conventions of her time. The novel uses humor and wit to expose the absurdities of the social hierarchy and the superficiality of certain characters.


"Pride and Prejudice" remains a classic not only for its engaging love story but also for its keen observations on human nature, societal expectations, and the complexities of interpersonal relationships. The exploration of pride and prejudice, both at the societal and individual levels, continues to resonate with readers across generations.



Pride


"Pride" by Ibi Zoboi explores contemporary themes within the context of a modern urban setting. While the novel is a retelling of Jane Austen's "Pride and Prejudice," Ibi Zoboi infuses it with her own unique perspective and explores themes that resonate with current social and cultural issues. Here are some of the key themes in "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi:


1.Cultural Identity:


The characters in "Pride" grapple with questions of cultural identity and belonging. Zuri Benitez, in particular, embodies the tension between preserving her cultural heritage and adapting to the changing environment. The novel examines how cultural identity is shaped by both individual choices and external influences.


2. Love and Relationships:


    Similar to "Pride and Prejudice," the theme of love and relationships is central to the narrative. Zoboi explores modern dynamics of love, including the challenges posed by social expectations, cultural differences, and the complexities of romance in a diverse and evolving community.


3. Family and Tradition:


   The novel delves into the importance of family and tradition. Zuri's close-knit family plays a significant role, and the story explores how familial bonds influence individual choices and perspectives. Traditional values are juxtaposed against the changing landscape of the neighborhood.


4. Social Class and Inequality:


    While "Pride and Prejudice" addressed issues of social class in 19th-century England, "Pride" tackles contemporary issues of social inequality. The disparities between the old and new residents of the neighborhood highlight broader social and economic disparities in urban settings.


5. Personal Growth and Transformation:


    The characters in "Pride" undergo personal growth and transformation. Zuri, much like Elizabeth Bennet in "Pride and Prejudice," experiences a journey of self-discovery and challenges her own prejudices. The theme of personal growth underscores the novel's exploration of individual agency and the capacity for change.


"Pride" by Ibi Zoboi not only pays homage to Jane Austen's classic but also brings forth contemporary themes that resonate with today's readers. Through its exploration of gentrification, cultural identity, and the complexities of modern love, the novel engages with pressing issues while maintaining a connection to the timeless themes of the original work.



Love and Transformation:


In both "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen and "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi, the themes of love and transformation are central to the narrative, illustrating the profound impact of romantic relationships on the characters' personal growth.


Pride and Prejudice:


  •   Love as a Catalyst for Change:


 The love story between Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy serves as a catalyst for transformative change. Initially clouded by misunderstandings, societal expectations, and personal pride, their evolving relationship becomes a vehicle for self-discovery and personal growth.


  •   Overcoming Prejudices:


 As Elizabeth and Darcy confront their own prejudices and biases, their love story becomes a journey of overcoming societal norms and expectations. Love becomes the force that challenges their preconceived notions, leading to a deeper understanding of themselves and each other.


Pride:


  •  Navigating Change in a Modern Setting:


Zuri Benitez and Darius Darcy's love story in "Pride" unfolds in a contemporary Brooklyn neighborhood undergoing significant changes. Their relationship mirrors the challenges faced by Elizabeth and Darcy, but in the context of gentrification, cultural identity, and evolving social dynamics.


  •   The Transformative Power of Love:


Love in "Pride" is portrayed as a transformative force that transcends societal divisions. Zuri and Darius navigate not only personal differences but also the external pressures of a changing community. Their love becomes a source of strength, challenging both internal and external obstacles.


Common Threads

 

Personal Growth:


 In both novels, the characters undergo significant personal growth through their romantic experiences. Love becomes a catalyst for self-reflection, challenging assumptions, and evolving beyond initial prejudices.


Breaking Societal Expectations:


The love stories defy societal expectations and norms. Whether in the Regency-era England of "Pride and Prejudice" or the contemporary Brooklyn of "Pride," the characters challenge the status quo and redefine the possibilities of love across social, cultural, and economic divides.


By comparing these two works, we see a continuity of the theme of love as a transformative and liberating force. The exploration of love in different contexts, eras, and societal settings underscores its universal and enduring nature, reinforcing its ability to drive personal and societal change.


Cultural Adaptation


Pride and Prejudice:












Jane Austen's novel intricately captures the subtleties and intricacies of English society in the early 19th century. Austen's work is a portrayal of the societal norms, class distinctions, and expectations prevalent during the Regency era. It immerses readers in the world of the English landed gentry, where the minutiae of social conduct, etiquette, and marriage prospects hold significant sway.


In "Pride and Prejudice," the characters are shaped by the expectations and constraints of their social milieu. The novel's setting, both geographically and temporally, contributes to the richness of the narrative. The English countryside becomes a backdrop for the interactions of the landed gentry, and the societal rituals of balls, visits, and courtship rituals are woven into the fabric of the story.


The cultural nuances extend to the characters' dialogues, behaviors, and choices. Austen's keen observations highlight the social hierarchies, the role of family connections, and the influence of reputation on individuals' prospects. The characters navigate a world where marriage is not merely a personal choice but a strategic move that carries implications for social standing and financial stability.


In essence, the cultural adaptation of "Pride and Prejudice" involves translating this intricate tapestry of social norms and expectations into different contexts. It requires a thoughtful reimagination of the setting, characters, and societal dynamics to resonate with audiences in diverse cultural and temporal landscapes. Whether transported to contemporary urban environments or different cultural milieus, the essence of cultural adaptation lies in capturing the timeless themes while giving the narrative a fresh and relatable perspective for a new audience.


Pride:










In "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi, the cultural adaptation takes a distinctive turn as Zoboi transports the narrative to a contemporary African American and Afro-Latino community. This adaptation provides a vibrant and modern lens through which to explore the timeless themes of Jane Austen's "Pride and Prejudice."


Zoboi's choice of setting in a diverse urban environment, specifically a neighborhood in Brooklyn, allows her to infuse the narrative with the rich tapestry of cultural identities and experiences. The characters, originally envisioned in early 19th-century England, are reimagined in a context that reflects the multiculturalism and complexity of modern-day America.


By embedding the story in an African American and Afro-Latino community, Zoboi not only introduces a diverse cast of characters but also explores contemporary issues such as gentrification, cultural identity, and the clash between tradition and change. The societal norms and expectations that shape the characters' lives are influenced by the complexities of urban life, offering a fresh perspective on the timeless themes of love, pride, and societal expectations.


In this cultural adaptation, Zoboi's narrative becomes a vehicle for capturing the nuances of relationships and individual journeys in a setting that resonates with a more diverse and contemporary readership. The characters grapple with personal growth, love, and societal pressures in a context that mirrors the multicultural reality of today's society, showcasing the adaptability and enduring relevance of Austen's themes across different cultural landscapes and time periods.



Conclusion:


In conclusion, the comparative analysis of "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen and "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi reveals a fascinating interplay between timeless themes and contemporary adaptations. While Austen's classic delves into the nuances of 19th-century English society, Zoboi skillfully transposes the narrative to a modern-day Brooklyn setting, addressing issues of race, gentrification, and cultural identity.


The parallels between characters like Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy in "Pride and Prejudice" and their modern counterparts, Zuri Benitez and Darius Darcy in "Pride," highlight the enduring nature of themes such as pride, prejudice, and the transformative power of love. Both novels emphasize personal growth and self-awareness as crucial elements in overcoming societal barriers to love.


Zoboi's adaptation serves as more than a mere retelling; it introduces a contemporary lens that offers social commentary on issues like gentrification and the preservation of cultural identity. In this way, "Pride" not only pays homage to Austen's timeless narrative but also contributes to the ongoing conversation about societal challenges in the present day.


In essence, through the exploration of pride, prejudice, and love, these two novels, separated by centuries and cultural contexts, demonstrate the universality of human experiences. "Pride" by Ibi Zoboi stands as a testament to the adaptability of Austen's themes, showcasing their r

elevance and capacity to resonate with readers across different times and places.


Reference:




  • Ibi Aanu zoboi, Pride. Thorndike Press, a Part of Gale, a Cengage Company, 2020. 




  • Words: 2664







Book Review: Not Here to Be Liked by Michelle Quach

“She never meant to start a movement. She just wanted what she earned.” Michelle Quach’s Not Here to Be Liked is a witty, sharp, and emotion...